Cleveland's great draft drought
Sunday, April 23, 2006
<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD>
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, arial, helvetica, sans-serif]By Steve Doerschuk REPOSITORY SPORTS WRITER[/FONT]
Browns. Cavs.
Prodigal brothers together in the sun today. Between landmark Saturdays.
The NFL team got a buzz going with free-agent signings that have fans fired up for the draft. The NBA team ended a 2,913-day drought between playoff games.
For seven seasons from 1998-99 through 2004-05, the Cavs were 207-335, a losing percentage of .667.
For seven years from 1999-2005, the Browns went 36-76, a losing percentage of .679.
You want those kind of numbers the way a golfer wants a 9 on a par 3.
The Browns have a better excuse. They were an expansion team. Both, though, were down for the same basic reason: Shanking high draft picks.
Dud drafts, dead drafts, doomed drafts. Drafts that didn’t generate enough wind to blow a cotton puff off a table.
Browns. Cavs. Guilty as charged.
One of them got an incredible reward for its multitude of draft sins — LeBron James.
But without whiffs on first-round picks from 1999 through 2002, there is no way the Cavaliers could have gotten to April 2003 with the 17-65 record that bought them enough ping-pong balls to win the lottery for James.
one no-brainer, one true find
General Manager Jim Paxson received and deserved no credit for spending the No. 1 overall pick on James. He’d have been tarred and feathered for taking anyone else.
Cavs owner Dan Gilbert fired Paxson last April, ending a run that began in 1998 when Paxson was hired as Wayne Embry’s protégé.
By the fall of 2004, Paxson was paying for a series of first-round mistakes. His one stroke of genius — taking Carlos Boozer in the second round in 2002 — turned sour when Boozer bolted after just two years with the team.
In re-making the team after Boozer’s exit, Paxson said, “My job is to provide Paul Silas as many resources as possible to win games.”
Yet, he had stuck the old head coach with the likes of DeSegana Diop, a No. 8 pick in 2001 who didn’t become a decent backup center until he left.
Silas didn’t last the 2004-05 season. Paxson did, but that was all.
Everyone knows of the Browns’ tortured draft history since they came back as an expansion team.
It can be argued that Paxson’s first-round drafting, excluding James, was worse than the football team’s.
Savage, Ferry know their roles
Both franchises aim to change their fortunes with young general managers.
The Browns’ Phil Savage, who turned 41 on April 7, will conduct his second draft next weekend.
The Cavs’ Danny Ferry, who turns 40 on Oct. 17, was hired a day before last June’s NBA draft.
The jury is out on Savage until his 2005 class starring Braylon Edwards, Brodney Pool and Charlie Frye makes its run through 2006.
The honeymoon is on for Ferry, whose free agency moves helped deliver a 50-win season but who didn’t have a draft pick last year.
Ferry didn’t return calls seeking input for this story. A liaison said, “He’s probably not going to get into what happened before he got here.”
Savage has been discrete about criticizing past drafts but did say, “This was a team that was devoid of a lot of young talent when we got here.”
He said the April 29-30 draft is important for three reasons.
“Obviously,” he said, “it’s the next step in the process of trying to rebuild. You do that from the inside out in the draft. Players grow inside our own building.
“Secondly, it’s an opportunity to continue to fill our holes, to play off of what we did in free agency.
“Thirdly, this is our second year together as a staff, from a coaching and scouting standpoint. We are trying to blend the two sides together. We can be more specific about what our needs are and how certain players are going to fit on our roster and within our scheme.”
No lebron to be found in NFL draft
Since basketball teams have five starters and football teams have 22, it is far easier for one superstar to change the world with the round ball.
James did.
The Browns, on the other hand, needed multiple draft hits to make that happen. They needed their two No. 1 overall picks, two No. 3 overall picks and a No. 6 overall pick to be cluster stars.
Tim Couch, Courtney Brown, Gerard Warren, Kellen Winslow Jr. and Braylon Edwards, however, have added up to one throbbing pain.
Bad luck plus bad judgment equal one large crater for Savage and Head Coach Romeo Crennel. It didn’t help that Savage’s first pick, Edwards, blew out a knee in December.
As Savage put it last week before going into seclusion for the draft, “This was a team that was devoid of a lot of young talent when we got here.”
More hurt than help is associated with all seven of the Browns’ first-round picks since 1999. This adds pressure to the management of Saturday’s first-round pick.
“We feel pretty good about our position, about what we’ve done with free agents,” Crennel said. “We’re gonna be better on paper.”
With that, Crennel looked at the paper he was holding and laughed. The paper will look different after Saturday, especially on the off chance Texas quarterback Vince Young falls to No. 12. Drafting Young would trigger a tidal wave of opinion, along the lines of Ferry when the Cavs acquired him in a blockbuster 1990 deal.
Ferry was going to be the next Larry Bird. He was more like the next Barry Clemens.
Will Young be a better version of Michael Vick, or get scrambled by NFL schemes? It’s Savage’s job to guess right.
“You don’t want to get caught with your pants down, not having done as much research as you could, particularly on first-round players,” Savage said. “In the seventh round, people aren’t going to care that much. People are watching the No. 12 pick pretty intently.”
playing ‘what if?’ with cavs
Because of the salary cap and free agency, no NBA team keeps years of draft classes together. It is amusing, though, to consider a Cavs’ dream team, made up of players who were passed over within the last 10 drafts.
Point guard: Steve Nash. He was available in 1996 when the Cavs picked Vitaly Potapenko at No. 12. The next five picks were Kobe Bryant, Predag Stojakovic, Nash, Tony Delk and Jermaine O’Neal.
Shooting guard: Bryant (see above) would work. But since Nash is the point guard, Michael Redd. The Ohio State scorer slipped to the second round in 2000. The Cavs spent the No. 7 pick on underwhelming center Chris Mihm.
Forward: Richard Jefferson. The Cavs could have had the mid-sized scorer in 2001 at No. 8, but preferred Diop, who totaled 40 points last season, when Jefferson averaged 22.2.
Forward: Ron Artest. The Cavs picked Trajan Langdon at No. 11 in 1999. The Bulls grabbed Artest five picks later.
Forward: Amare Stoudemire. The Suns got him after Cleveland took guard DaJaun Wagner at No. 6 in 2002.
Nash was league MVP last year. Redd averaged 25.1 points this year. Jefferson helped the Nets win a division title. Artest was NBA Defensive Player of the Year in 2004. Stoudemire averaged 26 points and nine rebounds last season to help the Suns finish 62-20.
At least the Cavs got an effective center in Zydrunas Ilgauskas with the 20th pick of the 1996 draft — eight spots after Potapenko.
For now, the gloom has passed. A wave of optimism has washed over the wayward basketball and football teams. There’s even a growing synergy between them.
“I love LeBron,” Browns linebacker Andra Davis said. “He’s the next Michael Jordan.”
Whether it is or isn’t a good thing, it’s a fact: The Cavs got bad enough to qualify for James, and now they’re in the playoffs.
The Browns? Perhaps they can make a move if knee surgeries work for Edwards and Winslow, and Dr. Phil does well in the operating room next weekend. Reach Repository sports writer Steve Doerschuk at (330) 580-8347 or e-mail:
[email protected]
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>