• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

BP Fantasy Baseball est. 2008 (Current Champion = Ahiacitian - Draft Wed., March 11, 7PM)

2 things I was thinking about changing

minimum innings pitched from 18 to 27

expanding playoffs from 6 to 8 teams

thoughts?
I will be contrarian on the playoff expansion. I like 6 teams because it rewards the top two teams for having the best season with a bye for the first round. And expanding to 8 playoff teams means you don’t even need to finish in the top half of the league to make the playoffs which seems a little weird to me. But hey, if you guys vote for it, then we might have an under .500 team taking home the crown, which would be the equivalent of the Carolina Panthers winning the super bowl this year!
 
Upvote 0
So far

4 yes to the 27 minimum ip

3 yes and 1 no to 8 team playoffs
I am definitely no to both. There needs to be some reward to finishing top 2 in the regular season. If you want to value SP more, minimum IP isn't it. Changing from K/9 to K's would do that in a heartbeat. I went through last year week by week. Not a single team had less than 27 IP in any week. So, it changes nothing. Changing the K/9 to K's would absolutely create the change you want.
 
Upvote 0
I am definitely no to both. There needs to be some reward to finishing top 2 in the regular season. If you want to value SP more, minimum IP isn't it. Changing from K/9 to K's would do that in a heartbeat. I went through last year week by week. Not a single team had less than 27 IP in any week. So, it changes nothing. Changing the K/9 to K's would absolutely create the change you want.

great points and makes perfect sense
 
Upvote 0
I don’t like changing the K/9 category to just strike outs because then that stat becomes an accumulator stat which encourages constant adding and dropping of pitchers. Whereas the K/9 stat reflects the quality of pitching each team has in a given week. In the current format, there are different strategies that managers currently employ. Some guys go reliever heavy in chasing saves, holds, and K/9, while others go more balanced or starting pitcher heavy in chasing wins, ERA, and WHIP.
 
Upvote 0
I don’t like changing the K/9 category to just strike outs because then that stat becomes an accumulator stat which encourages constant adding and dropping of pitchers.

i-can-totally-make-this-song-v0-f8pab63vukhd1.jpeg



none of us would ever bang the shit out of an obvious rule slip like that. It's like you remember the year it switched from K's to k/9.

:lol:
 
Upvote 0
I don’t like changing the K/9 category to just strike outs because then that stat becomes an accumulator stat which encourages constant adding and dropping of pitchers. Whereas the K/9 stat reflects the quality of pitching each team has in a given week. In the current format, there are different strategies that managers currently employ. Some guys go reliever heavy in chasing saves, holds, and K/9, while others go more balanced or starting pitcher heavy in chasing wins, ERA, and WHIP.
Maybe I’m not understanding, but pitchers are streamed ad nauseam in this league.
 
Upvote 0
Maybe I’m not understanding, but pitchers are streamed ad nauseam in this league.
Not by everyone, and it would be much worse if K/9 is changed to K’s! You can currently chase wins, saves, and holds because they are accumulator stats, but you aren’t guaranteed any of these stats when you are playing a starting pitcher or picking up a reliever to play. The only stat that truly rewards streaming is K’s because streaming starters guarantees increased K’s. However, K/9 rewards quality pitchers over quantity along with ERA and WHIP. For me personally, I see it as a quality vs quantity thing, and consider fantasy baseball the ultimate game of strategy that shouldn’t reward stacking mediocre starters for stat accumulation.

I actually think the relatively small roster sizes and limited number of bench slots also contributes to streaming pitching because there always pitching options on the waiver wire to pick up.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top