OSUBasketballJunkie
Never Forget 31-0
Dispatch
BIG TEN NOTEBOOK
Playing keepaway is risky
Punters often fail to execute when strategy makes sense
Wednesday, October 11, 2006
Rob Oller
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
</IMG> Ohio State?s Ted Ginn Jr. only got one chance to return a punt against Bowling Green, which decided to kick away from him.
Playing keepaway by punting and kicking the ball away from the other team?s dangerous return man is football?s equivalent of walking the home run hitter.
Sometimes, however, four balls become four balks, as was the case when Bowling Green botched four punts in an attempt to keep Ohio State?s Ted Ginn Jr. from burning them. Four of Bowling Green?s five punts traveled less than 30 yards before slicing out of bounds ? not exactly what the coaches had in mind.
But while the execution might have been awful, several Big Ten coaches agreed that the idea of intentionally punting out of bounds or pooching kickoffs is a solid concept.
The problem is pulling it off successfully.
"I think it makes a lot of sense, but it?s easier said than done," said Minnesota coach Glen Mason, who chose to kick to Ginn last season only to have him return the kick 100 yards for a touchdown.
Michigan State coach John L. Smith said it comes down to making a choice between the lesser of two evils when kicking to Ginn or Steve Breaston of Michigan.
"We had a guy (Breaston) last week and we have Teddy this week. I?m a big believer in not giving any of those guys any extra opportunities. If you can keep it away from them, that?s what you do," Smith said. "Now, what?s the best way to do that? Is it rolling out and keeping (the punt) on the ground? We tried that (in 2004) and Teddy ran one back against us."
Punting out of bounds is a solid option, although less experienced punters can cost their team more yardage than if they had kicked to the return man.
"It gets scary because a lot of times the kid ends up shanking it," Smith said. "It?s tough duty to get it enough yards downfield and yet keep it out of a guy?s hands."
The risk of shanking punts is why Ohio State and Michigan rely instead on increasing hang time and improving punt and kickoff coverage.
Manningham to miss game
Michigan sophomore receiver Mario Manningham will sit out Saturday at Penn State after undergoing arthroscopic knee surgery yesterday, coach Lloyd Carr said during the Big Ten weekly teleconference.
"He?ll miss this week, but we just got great news as far as the injury," Carr said, declining to elaborate.
Losing Manningham, who has eight touchdown catches in the past four games, means more playing time for senior Carl Tabb and freshman Greg Mathews, Carr said.
Paterno said no to Michigan
The Woody and Bo show might not have premiered in 1969 if Joe Paterno had said yes to an offer to coach the Wolverines.
Michigan coach Bump Elliott stepped down after the 1968 season, prompting former Michigan athletic director Don Canham to contact Paterno about the job.
"He offered me the job. I said, ?Let me think about it,? " Paterno said. "Don invited me to campus, but I didn?t want to do that. We met at the Pittsburgh airport ... and I told him the next day that I appreciated the offer but there were so many things I still want to get done.
"They probably look back now and, ?Thank God he turned us down.? They went out and got Bo Schembechler."
Paterno also told Canham that ?If I ever was going to leave Penn State for another college, it probably would be Michigan.? "
[email protected]
Upvote
0