• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Best CFB Players by Jersey Number

#7 - Danny Wuerrful

INSANE PICK over any of the following: Stanford QB John Elway; Notre Dame QB John Huarte; Miami (Ohio) QB Ben Roethlisberger; Virginia Tech QB Michael Vick.

Just to use some stats as the devil's advocate:

Wuerrfel won the Heisman and the NC in college.

Stanford was 9-3 and 8-4 in the 2 years before Elway, with bowl wins over LSU and Georgia. During Elway's 4 years, they were 3 games below .500 and never went to a bowl game (thanks to the play where the Cal guy runs into the trumpet player).

Of course, Bill Walsh left just as Elway was arriving; and Elway did set NCAA records for pass completions and 200-yard games during his college career. I think Elway was truly great, but the choice of Wuerrful can be justified looking only at college performances.
 
Upvote 0
In terms of impact on the program, and football in general, I think Michael Vick will be remembered as more significant than Wuerffel, Elway, or Roethlisberger at #7.

Wuerffel may have won a NC and a Heisman, but a number of kids could have stepped in at Florida into Spurrier's machine and done that. Wuerffel wasn't even the best QB at Florida under Spurrier's run, that was Rex Grossman. If Shawn Springs doesn't slip, the Gators finish #3 in the final polls.

Vick put Virginia Tech on the map, made them a legit national power, got them to a national championship game, and even was a catalyst in getting VT a juicy ESPN Thursday night, exclusive TV deal. Vick will go down as that program's Archie, or Chic, or whoever.
 
Upvote 0
WRONG.... Montana played alot as a sophomore and won a NC as a junior.

Actually, Joe played a little as a sophomore in 1975 (28 pass completions in 66 attempts), and missed 1976 due to injury. In his college careeer, he had a total of four (4) 200-yard passing days, and threw more interceptions (29) than TDs (27).

Here's the line from his final game, the legendary 'chicken soup' game, where Houston's coach (Bill Yeoman) made the mistake of putting in his backups while up 34-13 and ended up losing the game to an ND comeback:

13 of 34 for 163 yards, 1 TD and 3 Interceptions (although an ND site says 4 INT's).

They won the 1977 NC with him as QB (which never would have happened with the BCS in place, their media power got them a #5 ND vs. #1 Texas bowl matchup) - but Montana was not a superstar in college.
 
Upvote 0
Feldman's Blog:

College football's greatest legacy numbers

Ivan Maisel's series on the all-time numbers team got me thinking about the most storied legacy numbers in college football.

This is a bit of a dicey process since some schools have put their great jerseys out of commission, essentially stopping the legacy. But many schools still do treat a certain number as an honor for a prized player to wear.

My original choice for the top slot on the list was the No. 44 at Syracuse. It was the number worn by the great Jim Brown and was really made famous by Ernie Davis, who led the Orange to a national title and later won a Heisman Trophy. Davis, legend has it, actually chose Syracuse over Notre Dame because the school gave him the opportunity to wear No. 44. Floyd Little, another 'Cuse star, later donned the number, as did standout FB Rob Konrad, who was the last man to wear it. The university even changed its zip code from 13210 to 13244, too. But last November the number was retired, which ironically happened 44 years after Davis won the Heisman Trophy.

Anyhow, that's what this week's list is about, the greatest legacy numbers in college football.

1. Michigan's No. 1: This tradition started with Anthony Carter (the first time he touched the ball as a Wolverine came on a punt that he returned 78 yards for a touchdown) and has only grown over the last 25 years. The number has been passed down to other Michigan stars like Derrick Alexander, David Terrell and Braylon Edwards.

The story of Edwards and the No. 1 is especially telling. Back when Edwards first committed to Michigan in 2001, he told coach Lloyd Carr he wanted to wear the number of the receiver he grew up idolizing, Carter. That's because his father, former Wolverine RB Stanley Edwards, had spent years raving about his teammate Carter's greatness. The younger Edwards wanted to emulate that spirit. But Carr maintained that his young wideout wasn't ready for all that would come with the No. 1. Instead, he told Edwards he'd have to earn it first. A few spectacular seasons later, Edwards did that. He got his No. 1 and went on to win the 2004 Biletnikoff Award.

In April, Edwards' announced that he was giving a $500,000 scholarship endowment to the Michigan football player who wears the No. 1 jersey. If no player currently wears the No. 1 jersey, then the award will be granted to another player who exhibits exceptional off-field behavior and conducts himself as a team player.

2. Texas' No. 60: Even though UT is known for great running backs, and now Vince Young, a big chunk of Longhorn tradition was carved out by tough-guy LB Tommy Nobis, an Outland Trophy and Maxwell Award winner and the centerpiece of the 1963 national championship team. However, the No. 60 tradition at UT actually started with Johnny Treadwell, who took it over after teammate Bobby Goodwin was injured. (This Daily Texas story has more about how the tradition grew.)

Like most great traditions, UT's No. 60 has been saved for only the ones deemed very special. Texas standouts Robin Sendlein (1980), Jeff Leiding (1983) and Brit Hager (1988) all wore No. 60 during their senior seasons at linebacker. Hager, UT's all-time leading tackler, and Leiding both earned All-American honors. Brian Jones was the last to wear the number for an entire season, playing as No. 60 in 1989 and 1990. Two years ago, another UT star linebacker Derrick Johnson donned No. 60 for his last game as a Longhorn out of respect to the legacy. "After talking to Tommy Nobis and really understanding the history of the number, I thought it was important for me to wear it for this game to honor him and all of the guys that have worn it," Johnson said at the time.

3. Alabama's No. 12: The number itself always seemed to be "the" quarterback's number, but it seems to stand for something even more special at Alabama, where legends Joe Namath and Ken Stabler donned it. The legacy only grew stronger when favorite son Brodie Croyle did the number proud. Croyle battled through a pile of injuries and a staggering amount of coaching turnovers to have a great career in Tuscaloosa.

4. Notre Dame's No. 3: Joe Montana is the most famous ND player to have worn No. 3, although 1950s QB Ralph Guglielmi was good enough to finish fourth in the Heisman voting in 1954. He entered the College Football Hall of Fame in 2001. Two other hyped Irish quarterbacks were also given No. 3, Rick Mirer and Ron Powlus. Darius Walker, ND's starting TB, is currently doing just fine wearing it.

Walker, by the way, is only a junior so I guess high school senior/ND commitment Jimmy Clausen probably isn't starting out with No. 3 in 2007.

5. Ohio State's No. 36: Gotta love it when a running back's number gets dominated by linebackers. Growing up in the '70s and early '80s, this one symbolized hard-nosed linebackers since it was worn by Tom Cousineau, Marcus Marek and Chris Spielman, three Buckeye greats.

6. USC's No. 55: Tailback U. has produced more than its share of great defenders and many of the finest have worn No. 55. Of course, that was part of the sales pitch to land former Florida blue-chipper Keith Rivers, who has it now. Rivers, entering his junior season, is one of the Trojans' better defensive players but has been slowed by injuries for a large part of his career. He is hoping to follow in the class of previous Trojan greats: Junior Seau (1988-89), a 12-time NFL All-Pro linebacker; Willie McGinest (1990-93) and Chris Claiborne (1996-98), the school's first Butkus Award winner.

7. Miami's No. 5: One of the few jerseys that doesn't seem to fit a given position. Melvin Bratton, a standout Canes RB in the mid '80s and perhaps the godfather of Miami's swagger, was the first one to bring the number to prominence. Later All-American return man Kevin Williams wore No. 5. However, the number really came into prominence after Edgerrin James starred for the Canes and helped sparked a re-birth from the probation days. James' later stardom in the NFL or the fact that he donated a ton of money to UM (the team room in the football complex bears his name) only helped strengthen the legacy. Since he left UM, star WR Andre Johnson has worn No. 5 and so has safety Greg Threat, the team's leading tackler in 2004. Several incoming freshmen are already lobbying for the number now, including James' nephew Javarris.

8. Penn State's No. 31: The Nittany Lions have had a bunch of great linebackers, but there hasn't been many who have donned the same jersey number. This one was the one Shane Conlan made famous, and it was also worn by Andre Collins and Mac Morrison. Now, Paul Posluszny is taking it to another level.

9. Nebraska's No. 20: Johnny Rodgers' old jersey got a little more shine on it when Husker All-American safety Josh Bullocks wore it a few years ago. Currently, Marlon Lucky, a heavily touted tailback from the Los Angeles area, was given the number, although he has yet to emerge for Nebraska.

10. Mississippi's No. 38: This is a jersey that represents a lot more than just football talent. It honors the legacy of former Ole Miss DB Chucky Mullins, whose promising career was cut short after an injury in an Oct. 28, 1989 homecoming game against Vanderbilt left him paralyzed. For months, Mullins was hospitalized because of the life-altering injury. Finally, with support from not only the Oxford-area but nationwide, Mullins returned to Ole Miss in January 1990 to pursue his degree. Tragically, on May 1, 1991, as he prepared for class, he stopped breathing and passed away five days later. Every year a rising senior Rebel defensive player is honored with the Chucky Mullins Courage Award. This year, Rebels' star Patrick Willis, the nation's top MLB and the team's leader, will be wearing No. 38. In 2005, Willis led the nation in solo tackles (nine per game), despite playing his junior season with a broken middle finger on his right hand, a sprained left knee, a right mid-foot injury and a partial AC joint separation of his right shoulder.
 
Upvote 0
I can "see" it. Maybe
Me too, but by the same token, in a piece that seems to be heavily slanted towards the pre-WWII legends of the first half of the century, you have to have Chic Harley over Michael Irvin for #47. I don't deny that Irvin was a great, great college AND pro player, but of all the Buckeyes, Chic Harley HAS to be on that list.
 
Upvote 0
With 5 numbers in the first 60, it's not like tOSU is being slighted in the selection process

But it is amazing that neither Archie nor Chic Harley is one of the 5 selected so far.
 
Upvote 0
IMO Flutie always got way too much credit for the things he did. He won the Heisman over Byars simply b/c of a lucky pass. And I'm still trying to figure out why anyone in the world cares about his drop-kick extra point last year. A lot of hype for a meaningless, gimmick point in a meaningless game if you ask me.
 
Upvote 0
My 2 cents

Sammy Baugh IS a legend of the game - but I thnk moreso in the pros than college. I think he still holds some pro punting records, but not sure.
I fully expected to see him on this list, but didn't know he wore #45 in college - too bad, because Archie had a college career second to none.

Giving #47 to Irvin over Harley IS tragic.
I guarantee you that Red Grange will be the #77, and Chic Harley was just as good as Red Grange.

Angelo Bertelli, QB, Notre Dame over Gale Sayers? (or anyone else, for that matter)
yeah, right.

Even acknowledging that Ernie Davis was one of the best players of his generation, it is CRIMINAL not to list Jim Brown as the best #44.

The whole discussion about the best #7 will be moot in a couple of years anyway, so why worry about it?
 
Upvote 0
No kidding. They gave 45 to Sammy Baugh (QB, TCU, 1934-36)

Why Baugh and not two-time Heisman winner Archie Griffin? Not only was Baugh a great passer but he became the first great passing star the game ever had.

Baugh made his name as a pro, Archie as a collegiate. Had Archie gone on to be a star on the order of Emmit Smith in the pros the selection might have been different.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top