no, if we had gone 1 loss in 03 we still would not have played for a nc that year. we weren't an attractive team and wouldn't have gotten the votes.
a rematch is a very bad idea. even if we win decisevly the win would be considered tainted and many "experts" would dub it a split nc between tOSU and texas.
this year, anything less than a trip to the rose bowl was a let down. winning the big 10 and a bcs bowl will be great and memorable. but with the talent we have on both sides of the ball... this was the team tressel was supposed to use to prove that 02 wasn't a fluke. jury is still out sadly.