'98. Period.
PF: 430 PA: 144 = Avg score: 38-12
Failed to score 30 pts minimum only 3 times. Surrendered more than 14 points only four times, more than 17 points only once.
Big 10 finished that 1998/99 Bowl Season with a perfect 5-0 record, including Michigan defeating Arkansas (SEC runner-up), Ohio State defeating Texas A&M (Big-12 champs) and Wisconsin defeating UCLA (Pac-10 champs). For good measure, Purdue defeated Michael Bishop's KSU juggernaut (Big-12 runner-up), and Penn State defeated the Hal Mumme/Mike Leach designed Air Raid offense headed by Tim Couch at Kentucky.
Remember, Ohio State, Kansas State, Arizona and even Florida were all as deserving if not more so than FSU and Tennessee were of being in that Fiesta Bowl. The NC stinker pitted FSU, who pioneered from the dawn of the BCS the fact that it's good to lose early (so they've been doing it ever since - why mess with a good formula, huh?) and the worst Tennessee team in the last 10 years.