• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

A Look at Ohio State in Big Games Since 1969

Some of you want to highlight Ryan Day's 2-7 record versus top-5 opponents. It would be relatively easy to "defend" Day's performance in most of those games, but I'm not his defense attorney. Instead, I want to take a look at how some previous Buckeye head coaches fared in big (and little) games:

Woody Hayes

In his last ten seasons, Hayes had six legitimate chances to win national championships and blew all six of them. He posted a losing record against Michigan (4-5-1) including dropping his final three Games; and in bowl games (2-6); and against top-5 competition (4-8-2, going 0-4-1 in his last five attempts). In addition, Hayes lost three games as the #1 ranked team in the country, once to an unranked opponent (Michigan State, 1974); and lost two games as the #2 ranked team, once to an unranked opponent (Missouri, 1976).

1969: #1 Ohio State loses to #12 Michigan, costing the Buckeyes the consensus national championship
1970: #5 Ohio State defeats #4 Michigan
1970: #2 Ohio State loses to #12 Stanford in the Rose Bowl, costing the Buckeyes the AP national title
1971: Ohio State loses 4 games, including to #3 Michigan, to finish the season unranked
1972: #5 Ohio State loses to unranked Michigan State
1972: #9 Ohio State beats #3 Michigan
1972: #3 Ohio State gets blown out by #1 USC in the Rose Bowl, 42-17, costing the Buckeyes a national championship
1973: #1 Ohio State ties #4 Michigan
1973: #4 Ohio State beats #7 USC in the Rose Bowl to finish second in the AP Poll
1974: #1 Ohio State loses to unranked Michigan State
1974: #3 Ohio State beats #2 Michigan
1974: #3 Ohio State loses to #5 USC in the Rose Bowl, costing the Buckeyes the UPI (coaches) national title
1975: #1 Ohio State beats #4 Michigan
1975: #1 Ohio State loses to UCLA in the Rose Bowl, costing the Buckeyes the consensus national championship
1976: #2 Ohio State loses to unranked Missouri
1976: #8 Ohio State ties #4 UCLA
1976: #8 Ohio State loses to #4 Michigan, 22-0
1976: #11 Ohio State beats #12 Colorado in the Orange Bowl
1977: #4 Ohio State loses to #3 Oklahoma
1977: #4 Ohio State loses to #5 Michigan
1977: #9 Ohio State gets blown out by #3 Alabama, 35-6, in the Sugar Bowl
1978: #6 Ohio State loses to #5 Penn State, 19-0
1978: #14 Ohio State ties unranked SMU
1978: #16 Ohio loses to unranked Purdue
1978: #16 Ohio State loses to #6 Michigan
1978: #20 Ohio State loses to #7 Clemson in the Gator Bowl; Hayes punches an opposing player, gets fired the next morning

Earle Bruce

Bruce had one noteworthy season, 1979, his first in Columbus when he went 11-1 as Woody's replacement. In his remaining 8 seasons, Bruce compiled an uninspiring record of 70-31-1. Overall, Bruce had a record of 5-4 against Michigan; 5-3 in bowl games (but 0-2 in the Rose Bowl); and 1-3-1 against top-5 teams (his only win coming against #1 Iowa in 1985). In 1984, Bruce's #2 Buckeyes lost to unranked Purdue.

1979: #2 Ohio State beats #13 Michigan
1979: #1 Ohio State loses to #3 USC in the Rose Bowl, costing the Buckeyes a consensus national championship
1983: #6 Ohio State loses to #2 Oklahoma
1984: #2 Ohio State loses to unranked Purdue
1984: #6 Ohio State loses to #18 USC in the Rose Bowl
1985: #8 Ohio State beats #1 Iowa
1986: #9 Ohio State loses to #5 Alabama
1987: #7 Ohio State ties #4 LSU

John Cooper

I will spare you the details and give you just a synopsis of of the Cooper Era: 2-10-1 versus Michigan; 3-8 in bowl games (but with two of those wins coming in "BCS" bowls); and 2-8 against top-5 opponents (with both wins coming in 1996, against #3 PSU and #2 ASU). Cooper never won a national championship but twice finished #2 in the polls (1996 and 1998).

Jim Tressel

Tressel is beloved by Buckeye fans for his 2002 national championship, his excellent record against Michigan (9-1), and his decent showing in bowl games (6-4, but just 1-2 in national championship contests). Against top-5 competition, Tressel compiled a record of 4-7; he lost his final six games against top-5 opponents, with his last win coming in the epic 2006 Game versus Michigan. Four times Tressel lost a game as the #1 ranked team in the country, twice in national championship games (2006 and 2007); once to #18 Wisconsin (2010); and once to unranked Illinois (2007). Tressel's worst loss came in 2009 when his #7 Buckeyes lost to an unranked Purdue team that finished the season with a record of 5-7. Tressel was fired after the 2010 season (all wins vacated) for lying to the NCAA.

2002: #2 Ohio State beats #1 Miami to win the national championship
2003: #4 Ohio State loses to #5 Michigan
2005: #4 Ohio State loses to #2 Texas
2005: #4 Ohio State beats #5 Notre Dame
2006: #1 Ohio State beats #2 Texas
2006: #1 Ohio State beats #2 Michigan
2006: #1 Ohio State loses to #2 Florida, costing the Buckeyes the national championship
2007: #1 Ohio State loses to unranked Illinois
2007: #1 Ohio State loses to #2 LSU, costing the Buckeyes the national championship
2008: #5 Ohio State loses to #1 USC by the score of 35-3
2008: #10 Ohio State loses to #3 Penn State
2008: #10 Ohio State loses to #3 Texas
2009: #9 Ohio State loses to #3 USC
2009: #7 Ohio State loses to unranked Purdue
2010: #1 Ohio State loses to #18 Wisconsin

Interregnum

As the de facto interim head coach, Luke Fickell compiled a record of 6-7 (3-5 in the Big Ten) with losses to Michigan and to Florida in the Gator Bowl; Fickell did not face a top-5 opponent.

Urban Meyer

Urban Meyer was arguably the best head coach in the history of Ohio State football: his overall record was 83-9 (.902 winning percentage), and he was 7-0 versus Michigan, 5-2 in bowl games (2-1 in playoff games), and 6-2 versus top-5 competition, with three Big Ten titles (2014, 2017, 2018) and a national championship (2014). Even with all that success, Meyer had a few unfathomable lopsided losses to unranked teams during his tenure in Columbus: 2014 to Virginia Tech (35-21); 2017 to Iowa (55-24); and 2018 to Purdue (49-20), with the losses to Iowa and Purdue costing Ohio State a spot in the playoffs.

2014: #8 Ohio State loses to unranked Virginia Tech by the score of 35-21
2014: #4 Ohio State beats #1 Alabama in the Sugar Bowl
2014: #4 Ohio State beats #2 Oregon to win the national championship
2016: #2 Ohio State loses to unranked Penn State
2016: #2 Ohio State beats #3 Michigan
2016: #3 Ohio State loses to #2 Clemson by the score of 31-0
2017: #2 Ohio State loses to #5 Oklahoma
2017: #6 Ohio State beats #2 Penn State
2017: #6 Ohio State loses to unranked Iowa by the score of 55-24, costing the Buckeyes a playoff bid
2017: #8 Ohio State beats #4 Wisconsin
2018: #2 Ohio State loses to unranked Purdue by the score of 49-20, costing the Buckeyes a playoff bid
2018: #10 Ohio State beats #4 Michigan

Ryan Day

Despite having an overall record of 61-9, Ryan Day has developed a reputation for losing big games: he is 1-3* versus Michigan; 2-4 in bowl games; and 2-7 versus top-5 competition. However, unlike Urban Meyer and to some extent Jim Tressel, Day doesn't inexplicably lose games that he is supposed to win, with his "worst" loss coming against #12 Oregon in the 2021 season.

2019: #2 Ohio State loses to #3 Clemson
2020: #3 Ohio State beats #2 Clemson
2020: #3 Ohio State loses to #1 Alabama costing the Buckeyes the national championship
2021: #2 Ohio State loses to #5 Michigan*
2022: #2 Ohio State beats #5 Notre Dame
2022: #2 Ohio State loses to #3 Michigan*
2022: #4 Ohio State loses to #1 Georgia
2023: #2 Ohio State loses to #3 Michigan*
2024: #2 Ohio State loses to #3 Oregon
 
Last edited:

1. Jan. 3, 2003 (National Championship Game): Ohio State 31, Miami 24 (2OT)



As great as Ohio State’s last two national title runs were, the Buckeyes’ first national championship game win of the 21st century reigns supreme as Ohio State’s greatest victory of the last 25 years.

Going into the 2003 BCS National Championship Game, Miami had established itself as the powerhouse team in college football. “The U” had won 34 straight games dating back to 2000 and was chasing its second consecutive national title. Ohio State entered the national championship game as an 11.5-point underdog, the largest underdog Ohio State has been in any game since the turn of the century.

Much like the Alabama game 12 years later, the favorite looked like the better team early on. The Hurricanes’ vaunted defense forced punts or turnovers on Ohio State’s first five possessions, including a fake field goal attempt by the Buckeyes. Miami took a first-quarter lead on a 25-yard touchdown pass from Ken Dorsey to Roscoe Parrish.

The first turning point of the game came when Mike Doss intercepted Dorsey and returned the ball to the 17-yard line. Ohio State took advantage of the short field and tied the game on a Craig Krenzel touchdown run. Ohio State’s defense gave the Buckeyes the ball in the red zone again when Kenny Peterson hit Dorsey to force a fumble that Darrion Scott recovered. The Buckeyes capitalized on prime field position again, taking the lead on a Maurice Clarett touchdown run.

Krenzel briefly threw away a chance to take a two-score lead when Sean Taylor picked him off in the end zone, but Clarett made an all-time hustle play by stripping the ball out of Taylor’s hands to give the Buckeyes the ball back at the 28-yard line. Ohio State took a 10-point lead on a 44-yard field goal by Mike Nugent.

Miami made it a three-point game later in the third quarter on a Willis McGahee touchdown run. The Hurricanes’ next drive stalled after McGahee suffered a severe knee injury, and Todd Sievers missed a potential game-tying field goal wide right. Following a 42-yard miss by Nugent, Miami squandered another scoring opportunity when Dustin Fox forced a Parrish fumble that Will Allen recovered. But Miami’s defense forced a Buckeye punt, which Roscoe Parrish returned 50 yards to set up a game-tying 40-yard field goal for Sievers at the end of regulation, sending the national championship game to overtime for the first time ever.

The Hurricanes started the first overtime with the ball and took the lead on a 7-yard touchdown pass from Dorsey to Kellen Winslow II. Miami’s defense subsequently sacked Krenzel to bring up a 4th-and-14, but just like they did at Purdue, Krenzel and Jenkins saved the season again with a 17-yard connection for a first down.

After forcing another fourth down on Ohio State’s subsequent set of downs, Miami initially appeared to win the game when Krenzel’s pass to Chris Gamble went off of Gamble’s hands in the end zone. In one of the most debated calls in college football history, however, Miami’s Glenn Sharpe was called for pass interference. Ohio State received a new set of downs and took advantage, with Krenzel running for a 1-yard touchdown to tie the game.

Having cheated death twice in the first overtime, Ohio State needed only five plays to take the lead in the second overtime, pulling ahead 31-24 on a 5-yard touchdown run by Clarett. Miami converted a pair of first downs on its ensuing possession, including a 4th-and-3 completion from Dorsey to Winslow. Following a pair of penalties against the Buckeyes, Miami had four downs to gain just two yards for a game-tying touchdown.

But after Jarrett Payton gained just one yard on 1st-and-goal, Dorsey’s second-down pass attempt fell incomplete and Quadtrine Hill was stuffed for no gain on 3rd-and-goal. On 4th-and-goal from the 1-yard line, Cie Grant burst through the line to hit Dorsey and force an incomplete pass, securing Ohio State’s first national title in 34 years.

Ohio State became the first-ever 14-0 team in college football history, and it did so by beating a team that hadn’t lost in more than two years. It remains one of the biggest upsets ever in the national championship game, and it firmly reestablished Ohio State as one of college football’s elite programs, a status it’s maintained ever since.

Doing all of that in a down-to-the-wire thriller with an unforgettable ending made the Buckeyes’ 2002 win over Miami the clear choice for Ohio State’s best game of the quarter-century.

 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Back
Top