• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

2026 College Football Playoff Discussion

So the committee is using the same metric that ESPN is using - conference weight by Intra-conference play… and the conference that they are favoring is being justified by cramming more of their schools into the Top 25 to justify losses to Top 25 teams during Intra-conference play?





So, ESPN has cooked up a "metric" where SEC losses don't matter, and the CFP committee has taken it and ran with it? That's awesome for the sport.
 
Upvote 0
It’s definitely being noticed by everyone outside the hype machine.



"intra conference strength" that's completely based on the committees initial subjective decision to completely over value the mediocre SEC teams over the mediocre teams of other conferences. All you can do is laugh.
 
Upvote 0
So the committee is using the same metric that ESPN is using - conference weight by Intra-conference play… and the conference that they are favoring is being justified by cramming more of their schools into the Top 25 to justify losses to Top 25 teams during Intra-conference play?




It’s such a good thing there will be a 24-team playoff for the next 5 years that will be entirely shown by espn/ABC.

Thanks, Petitti.
 
Upvote 0
So... I hate that this might be part of their thought process, but is there a chance that they look at who the teams are and the number of viewers they're expected to bring? I mean let's say it comes down to Ohio State and Wake Forest - you can only take one. How much do you consider the fact that Ohio State is Ohio State and Wake Forest is Wake Forest? And I'm not talking about what's on happening on the field. Or Ohio State vs. BYU or even Indiana. Ohio State has a card to play over Indiana, since they played and beat Indiana.
Absolutely that’d come into play if Wake were to lose again. I don’t think we can jump them if they have 1 loss.
 
Upvote 0
Remember when they did this with Boise and the mid majors back in the early 2000’s?

Just shamelessly pumped them up like the rest of the world was too stupid to notice?

Well those mid majors have had a chance to see the field regularly with the big boys since and the hype machine has fallen silent.

This is why, once you are on the playoff path anyway, I like the idea of 24 teams and an all P4 regular season. Make everyone play everyone and all this rankings nonsense goes away (too a large degree).
 
Upvote 0
The "overall body of work" crap only applies to the wins when it comes to the SEC, the complete ignoring of losses is the huge problem.

Even then I still don't know how you can justify Bama being #3.

I'm guessing they are anticipating Bama losing to Auburn or in the SECCG and are propping them up high enough that they don't even have to explain away why they are still in with 3 losses and zero quality wins.
How about Texas at 5. They have to be the most chaotic team I’ve ever watched
 
Upvote 0
Remember when they did this with Boise and the mid majors back in the early 2000’s?

Just shamelessly pumped them up like the rest of the world was too stupid to notice?

Well those mid majors have had a chance to see the field regularly with the big boys since and the hype machine has fallen silent.

This is why, once you are on the playoff path anyway, I like the idea of 24 teams and an all P4 regular season. Make everyone play everyone and all this rankings nonsense goes away (too a large degree).

The goal should be a normalized scheduling format so we can simply use records and actual tiebreakers. Too many self interested parties to let the human element in this much, the subjectivity needs to go.
 
Upvote 0
The goal should be a normalized scheduling format so we can simply use records and actual tiebreakers. Too many self interested parties to let the human element in this much, the subjectivity needs to go.
100%

Imagine the shitshow of trying to rank the NFL 1-32. Its completely subjective and open to manipulation because of all the money at stake.

It's up there with daylight savings time as stupid shit from the distant past that I can't believe is still used today.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top