• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

2026 College Football Playoff Discussion

So... I hate that this might be part of their thought process, but is there a chance that they look at who the teams are and the number of viewers they're expected to bring? I mean let's say it comes down to Ohio State and Wake Forest - you can only take one. How much do you consider the fact that Ohio State is Ohio State and Wake Forest is Wake Forest? And I'm not talking about what's on happening on the field. Or Ohio State vs. BYU or even Indiana. Ohio State has a card to play over Indiana, since they played and beat Indiana.
 
Upvote 0
but is there a chance that they look at who the teams are and the number of viewers they're expected to bring?

I am not disagreeing with you on anything Zurp - but they left out two loss ND last year so IDK how much viewership factors into the decision.

Is Ohio State basically rooting for Texas Tech, BYU, Wake and Tennessee to lose?
 
Upvote 0
…

Is Ohio State basically rooting for Texas Tech, BYU, Wake and Tennessee to lose?
You already know the answer to this…

In every part of that which is Ohio State: administration, staff, players, band, media, trainers, support, cheerleaders, truck drivers, concessions, fans… every single part is made up of different people who want different things.

Some want Ohio state to make it into the playoffs, so they want whatever would make that happen. For my part: just beat TTUN. Sure, try to win in Lincoln, ok. But above all beat TTUN. Anything else is details
 
Upvote 0
You already know the answer to this…

In every part of that which is Ohio State: administration, staff, players, band, media, trainers, support, cheerleaders, truck drivers, concessions, fans… every single part is made up of different people who want different things.

Some want Ohio state to make it into the playoffs, so they want whatever would make that happen. For my part: just beat TTUN. Sure, try to win in Lincoln, ok. But above all beat TTUN. Anything else is details
Agreed. I also want them to get into any bowl game so these young players continue to get practice time and one more shot at a game experience.
 
Upvote 0
Tennessee losing to LSU is obviously the easiest outcome to help this weekend.

Think BYU might lose @ Kansas. Kansas is 4-6 but they aren't awful. Good dual threat QB and their D shut down a pretty good WVU offense this last week. BYU also has not been good on the road either.

Indiana going down @ Washington feels very possible as well. Indiana has been living on the edge, and while Washington has been mediocre this year, that's still a tough road trip
 
Upvote 0
For reference

Indiana (1 loss) dropped 5 spots for having a BYE week between the 11/3 and 11/10 rankings.......

South Carolina this week only dropped 4 spots after losing by 4 TDs to an awful Arkansas team who had 1 win against a P4 team coming into the game (Vanderbilt) to take their 4th loss of the season
 
Upvote 0
The "overall body of work" crap only applies to the wins when it comes to the SEC, the complete ignoring of losses is the huge problem.

Even then I still don't know how you can justify Bama being #3.

I'm guessing they are anticipating Bama losing to Auburn or in the SECCG and are propping them up high enough that they don't even have to explain away why they are still in with 3 losses and zero quality wins.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The "overall body of work" crap only applies to the wins when it comes to the SEC, the complete ignoring of losses is the huge problem.

Even then I still don't know how you can justify Bama being #3 considering they've not beaten a single team who is currently ranked. I guess that's when they start pushing the "well this team was ranked when they beat them" garbage.

I'm guessing they are anticipating Bama losing to Auburn or in the SECCG and are propping them up high enough that they don't even have to explain away why they are still in with 3 losses and zero quality wins.

It's always been bad but this level of cooking the books is insane. It's fucking WWE.
 
Upvote 0
It's always been bad but this level of cooking the books is insane. It's fucking WWE.

I actually think the CFP was pretty fair in the 1st 2 years of the 12 teamer (I mean they did put SMU in over Bama in year 1). They've definitely decided to go off the rails with the pro SEC SEC SEC water carrying this year though.

This has awful implications going forward into the 24-team era unfortunately. If they keep up with this mindset, we are looking at 8-10 SEC teams in the playoff every year. Since SEC teams can lose 4 games and it be "no big deal" according to the current "criteria" of the committee.

Can you ever imagine a world where Illinois takes their 4th loss losing by 4 TDs to Rutgers and still remains in the top 25? That's basically the equivalent of what they are doing with teams like South Carolina.
 
Upvote 0
So the committee is using the same metric that ESPN is using - conference weight by Intra-conference play… and the conference that they are favoring is being justified by cramming more of their schools into the Top 25 to justify losses to Top 25 teams during Intra-conference play?



 
Upvote 0
Back
Top