In my mind, '07 down the stretch was the worst when you look at how good the guys we missed ended up being (difference between Rose and Sugar appearances vs. NC Games imo):
DE Devon Still (All Big Ten), OG Barksdale (all jokes aside a solid contributor at LSU), TE Gronkowski (top TE in the NFL), LB Martez Wilson (good player for Illinois), DT Josh Brent (ditto), S Major Wright (tremendous player and third round pick), DE Ben Martin (could've been great, injuries), RB Spencer Ware (great RB for LSU), OT Anthony Davis (arguably the one that hurt most, first round pick), DE Derrick Morgan (great DE for GATech)...those come to mind first anyways.