• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Who's the Greatest Buckeye Football Player? (Vote for THREE)

Who's the Greatest Buckeye Football Player? (Vote for 3)

  • Hopalong Cassady

    Votes: 37 33.3%
  • Archie Griffin

    Votes: 102 91.9%
  • Chic Harley

    Votes: 51 45.9%
  • Les Horvath

    Votes: 11 9.9%
  • Vic Janowicz

    Votes: 22 19.8%
  • Orlando Pace

    Votes: 44 39.6%
  • Chris Spielman

    Votes: 22 19.8%
  • Jack Tatum

    Votes: 16 14.4%
  • Other

    Votes: 14 12.6%

  • Total voters
    111

LordJeffBuck

Illuminatus Emeritus
Staff member
BP Recruiting Team
Okay, it's Michigan week, so it's time for a special "Greatest Buckeye Ever" poll. Now it's your chance to vote for the greatest Buckeye football player of all time, regardless of position or era. Here are your choices (Please make THREE selections):

Hopalong Cassady (1952-55). Cassady is known as one of the greatest running backs in Ohio State history (2,466 yards, 5.67 ypc), but he also started at cornerback for the Buckeyes (10 interceptions, including an 88-yard touchdown return against Wisconsin in 1954). During his Ohio State career (36 games), Hopalong amassed 4,403 all-purpose yards, scored 37 touchdowns, was a two-time unanimous All American, won the 1955 Heisman Trophy, and led the Buckeyes to the 1954 national championship.

Archie Griffin (1972-75). An obvious choice for this poll, Archie was a three-time All American (1973-75), a two-time Heisman winner (1974-75), and remains Ohio State's all-time leading rusher (5,589 yards, 121.5 yards per game, 6.05 ypc, 34 games over 100 yards). In addition to the individual accomplishments, Archie led the Buckeyes to a 40-5-1 record and four straight Big Ten titles during his time in scarlet and grey.

Chic Harley (1916-17, 1919). According to Archie Griffin, "Chic put Ohio State football on the map," and Ohio Stadium is still known as "The House That Harley Built". Harley was a consensus All American for each of his three seasons, and he led the Buckeyes to a 21-1-1 overall record and two outright Big Ten championships during that time. Chic scored 23 touchdowns, 8 field goals, and 35 PAT's in just 23 games for Ohio State. In 1950, Harley was named a member of the AP college All Star team for the first half of the 20th century.

Les Horvath (1940-42, 1944). In 1942, Horvath helped lead Ohio State to a 9-1-0 record and the school's first recognized national championship; just two years later, he was an integral member of the 1944 squad that finished a perfect 9-0-0 and won the so-called "civilian national championship". Horvath led the Big Ten in rushing and total yards as a senior, and won the 1944 Heisman Trophy.

Vic Janowicz (1949-51). Janowicz is often considered the greatest all-around player in the history of Ohio State football. During his three years with the Buckeyes, Vic played quarterback, halfback, and defensive back, plus handled the punting, place kicking, and return duties. After his outstanding junior season (1950), Janowicz won the Heisman Trophy.

Orlando Pace (1994-96). Many consider Pace to be the best offensive lineman in the history of college football. In only three years at Ohio State, Orlando was a two-time unanimous All American (1995-96), and won the Lombardi Award twice (1995-96) and the Outland Trophy once (1996); he also finished fourth in the 1996 Heisman balloting. Pace single-handedly put the term "pancake block" into the college football lexicon, and he did not yield a sack during his final two seasons in Columbus.

Chris Spielman (1984-87). Spielman was the best linebacker in Ohio State history, and that is saying something given the number of great players at that position. Chris is the Buckeyes' career leader in solo tackles with 283 (his 546 total tackles puts him in third place), and he is perhaps best remembered for his epic 29-tackle performance against Michigan in 1986. Chris was a two-time consensus All American (1986-87), and he won the Lombardi Award after his senior season.

Jack Tatum (1968-70). Nicknamed "The Assassin", Jack Tatum was a player whom Buckeye opponents truly feared. A two-time unanimous All American selection, Tatum led the Buckeyes to a 27-2 record, three Big Ten championships (two outright), and two national championships (one consensus) during his three years in Columbus. He was also named the National Defensive Player of the Year in 1970.
 
daveeb;991841; said:
Archie, Pace, Spielman.


Spiels is my all time favorite Buckeye, the only jersey I'll wear, but he isn't one of the 3 best players all time at OSU.

I could see an argument for Pace but I personally feel Hicks and Marshall were just as good, they just didn't get the pub that Pace did.

Tough, tough, tough list. Hate like hell to ever see Hop and Les left off but to me its pretty clear. Hope someone puts in at least one vote for Hop, I want to puke seeing him sitting on zero.
 
Upvote 0
I'll take the first three off your list please LJB - though all are great choices, I really like the list as a whole.

Without Chic there is probably no Buckeye football, no Shoe, no legends to follow. He is an automatic Shoe-In.

Cassady over Jancowicz was tough to do - both resumes are damned near untouchable - as is ...

Archie - 2-time Heisman winner, all Buckeye, and a great ambassador for the University to this day.

I would also like to give an honorary mention to Jack Tatum, specifically in recognition of it being 5 days away from The Game. If there is one way for our Defensive coaches to make up for any omissions on their part it is to let slip the dogs of war against TSUN. We need big hits, we need turnovers, we need havoc - we need mental and physical domination. Just the kind of play the legendary Tatum would bring.
 
Upvote 0
sandgk;991881; said:
...

Cassady over Janowicz was tough to do - both resumes are damned near untouchable - as is ...


I did exactly the same, and I agonized over it for some reason. It was the hardest choice of all of these polls for me.

To me it came down to Cassady as a DB. Janowicz was awesome by all accounts, but Hop was an all-timer in the secondary.
 
Upvote 0
Troy didn't even make the list???

3-0 against Michigan, and a Heisman trophy?

I mean I know he didn't win the NC, but he is THE wolverine-killer, not to mention he represents the University with as much class as any other Buckeye ever.
 
Upvote 0
Pace...possibly the most dominant Buckeye ever.

Archie...

and when I think of "football player" I think of nasty, dirty, grind it out, get it done no matter what, smashmouth, leave your heart on the field...just like Spielman.

I know the guys from the early days of the program were great, but these are the guys I grew up with. Biased? Of course, but in a poll like this, there isn't a wrong answer.
 
Upvote 0
BB73;991992; said:
I voted for Chic and Archie - I think those are easy decisions.

Then I went with Orlando Pace over 3 Heisman winners.

Ditto on that. Chic and Arch to start, without question.

No doubt in my mind that Les, Vic, and Hop were also incredible players, but I went with what I remember, which is Orlando Pace eating DE's for breakfast.
 
Upvote 0
1. Pace - probably the most dominating player at his position in the history of college football.

2. Cassady - All American talent at two positions, won the Heisman and a national championship.

3. Harley - the man "put Ohio State football on the map".

Hard to leave Archie off the list ... and Spielman is perhaps my favorite Buckeye ever.

ScarletBlood31;991888; said:
Troy didn't even make the list???

3-0 against Michigan, and a Heisman trophy?

I mean I know he didn't win the NC, but he is THE wolverine-killer, not to mention he represents the University with as much class as any other Buckeye ever.
Some of the guys who didn't make the list - Troy, Eddie, Hawk, Doss, Willis, Gradishar, Parker, Hicks - would be no brainers at 90% of the other schools, but their absence shows you the greatness of Ohio State's football tradition.
 
Upvote 0
LordJeffBuck;992015; said:
1. Pace - probably the most dominating player at his position in the history of college football.

2. Cassady - All American talent at two positions, won the Heisman and a national championship.

3. Harley - the man "put Ohio State football on the map".

Hard to leave Archie off the list ... and Spielman is perhaps my favorite Buckeye ever.


Some of the guys who didn't make the list - Troy, Eddie, Hawk, Doss, Willis, Gradishar, Parker, Hicks - would be no brainers at 90% of the other schools, but their absence shows you the greatness of Ohio State's football tradition.


True.

I'm probably just not old enough to appreciate the entirety of all tOSU history, and a lot of the great players that I wasn't alive to see.
 
Upvote 0
ScarletBlood31;991888; said:
Troy didn't even make the list???

3-0 against Michigan, and a Heisman trophy?

I mean I know he didn't win the NC, but he is THE wolverine-killer, not to mention he represents the University with as much class as any other Buckeye ever.

You have to be 5 years removed from school to be elligible for this list (I actually just made that up but it is a good rule)
 
Upvote 0
I voted for Harley, Griffin and "other". The other is Bill Willis. After hearing his story, I will always consider him near the top of OSU greats. It shames me that I'd only heard his story in the last couple years. At least he's finally getting some of the credit he's always been due.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top