• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

vBook: Scarlet vs Gray

Jump to latest Follow Reply
Sort by date Sort by votes
CleveBucks

CleveBucks

Serenity now
Scarlet vs. Gray. Who wins?

Scarlet:

QBs: Troy Smith, Rob Schoenhoft
RBs: Erik Haw, Chris Wells, Ryan Franzinger, Dionte Johnson, Lane (?)
WRs: Derek Harden, Tony Gonzalez, Brian Hartline, Devon Lyons, Brent Ullery, Dre Riddick
TEs: Rory Nicol, Will Crall
OL: Doug Datish, Tim Schafer, Tyler Whaley (C), Jon Skinner (C), Steve Rehring, Kyle Mitchum, Dan Dye
DL: David Patterson, Juan Garnier, Jay Richardson, Vernon Gholston, Doug Worthington, Todd Denlinger
LB: Ross Homan, Curtis Terry, Larry Grant, Austin Spitler
S: Jamario O'Neal, Nick Patterson, Curt Lukens, Marcus Williams
CB: Antonio Smith, Donald Washington, Kurt Coleman, Brandon Underwood, Zach Willis
K: Ryan Pretorius, Andrew Good
P: A.J. Trapasso (first overall pick)
LS: Dimitros Makridis (?)

Coaches: Bollman, D. Tressel, Fickell, D. Hazell, Beckman

Gray:

QBs: Justin Zwick, Todd Boeckman, Ben Kascandi
RBs: Maurice Wells, Joe Gantz, Trever Robinson
WRs: Roy Hall, Ted Ginn, Brian Robiskie, Albert Dukes, Dan Potokar, Kyle Ruhl (?)
TEs: Marcel Frost, Brandon Smith, John Larson.
OL: T.J. Downing, Jim Cordle (C), Andrew Moses (C), Alex Boone, Ben Person, Josh Kerr, Doug Ebner
DL: Joel Penton, Quinn Pitcock, Lawrence Wilson, Alex Barrow, Ryan Williams, Nader Abdallah.
LB: Mike D'Andrea, Marcus Freeman, Ryan Lukens, James Laurinaitis, Chad Hoobler
S: Brandon Mitchell, Anderson Russell, Michael Dougherty, Daniels (?)
CB: Mike Roberts, Malcolm Jenkins, Andre Amos, Sirjo Welch, DeAngelo Haslam
K: Aaron Pettrey, Jon Skeete, Michael Mattimoe
P: Jon Thoma
LS: Drew Norman, Matt Drummelsmith (?)

Coaches: Heacock, Daniels, Peterson, Haynes
 
Finally, a game where you can bet against the Bucks and feel OK about it.

(BTW - I will be out of town after the game for two weeks so can somebody else settle this one?)
 
Upvote 0
If Scarlet can run the ball well (ie 150+ yards) they will probably win. Scarlet has a big advantage at QB IMO. Smith is best when he can run and won't be playing long enough to get in a groove anyway. From what I've heard from my sources TB has been a lot more impressive than RS this spring. Zwick will probably be able to put up some good numbers with Ginn, Hall, Frost, et al to throw to for the short time that he is in the game. Mo Wells is going to have to have a good day.

I'll pick Gray. Where's the vbet?
 
Upvote 0
exhawg said:
If Scarlet can run the ball well (ie 150+ yards) they will probably win. Scarlet has a big advantage at QB IMO. Smith is best when he can run and won't be playing long enough to get in a groove anyway. From what I've heard from my sources TB has been a lot more impressive than RS this spring. Zwick will probably be able to put up some good numbers with Ginn, Hall, Frost, et al to throw to for the short time that he is in the game. Mo Wells is going to have to have a good day.

I'll pick Gray. Where's the vbet?
Click to expand...

I just put a vbet on Scarlet, so it's up as far as I know.

Here it is...

http://www.buckeyeplanet.com/forum/showthread.php?t=24212
 
Upvote 0
Posted this in the other thread, i'm betting on Gray

----------------------------------------------------------------------

QB's = Pretty even but scarlet with a slight advantage. Troy and Zwick only getting a quarter and Troy being limited on running makes the scarlet lead very slight to me.

RB = Scarlet by a landside.

WR = Gray by a mile. Ginn and Gonzo cancel each other out, with me prefering Ginn a little anyways. Gray's supporting recievers kill scarlets in my prediction, although I'm a Hartline fan.

TE = A tie.

OLine- I'm shocked Whaley was the first Center picked. I like Gray better, but not by a lot because Downing has a restriction.

DLine - If Pitcock is healthy then I have it a draw otherwise Scarlet gets the nod.

LB = I like gray a lot better if D'animal can play, and still better even if he can't.

Corner = Jenkin and Amos should give gray the advantage here.

K: Scarlet by a little
Punt: Scarlet by a lot.
LS: Umm Gray?

Final: Scarlet 4 Gray 4 (Some half points and ties finalized my score on position.) So it looks pretty even to me.

Edit: The more I think about it the more I want to make the QB a draw. I think Scarlet has the Special Teams and the running backs and that's it. Gray wins.
 
Upvote 0
My Picks

On O-Zone they say the following people aren't playing or have restrictions:

Prior to the draft, a number of players were designated as either medically unavailable or players whose playing time would be limited. The players who will not participate in the spring game for medical reasons include Kirk Barton, Doug Datish, Tyson Gentry, Devin Jordan, Shaun Lane, David Lisko, Antonio Pittman and Kyle Ruhl on offense. On defense, Mike D'Andrea, Curt Lukens, Quinn Pitcock, Ryan Williams and Doug Worthington are all out due to medical problems.
Additionally, David Patterson is limited to playing the first quarter only. Jay Richardson, T. J. Downing, Anthony Gonzalez, Ted Ginn will be limited to play in the first two periods only. Troy Smith and Justin Zwick will play just one period and will be required to wear black, no-contact jerseys.

http://www.theozone.net/football/2006/Springball/draft.htm

I agree with your assessement above me here, but I have to say Scarlet has the advantage with LB, S, and P. That put me over the top.

Pitcock won't play.
​
 
Upvote 0
BuckBojangles said:


I agree with your assessement above me here, but I have to say Scarlet has the advantage with LB, S, and P. That put me over the top.

Pitcock won't play.
​
Click to expand...

Good call on the safety, I agree I overlooked that position when breaking it down (imo). I agree safety is stronger on scarlet; Linebacker we will agree to disagree on, and punter well you don't have any arguement here :)
 
Upvote 0
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top