Troy Smith vs. Marcus Vick

[avoiddallyod]

Just a question as to what everybody thinks....

Vick-69.0 pass. percent, 1534 pass yards,11-5 tdown/Int, 319 rushing yards

Smith-59.7 pass percent,1265 pass yards,10-3 tdown/Int, 378 rushing yards

 

[NFBuck]

Uhhhh, after watching today's games, I take Troy 100-100 times. No question.

 

[avoiddallyod]

Well what if you could choose who to run Tosu offense?

 

[NFBuck]

The only person I take over Troy to run OUR offense at this point is Vince Young.

 

[kippy1040]

I would go with Troy Smith. Threee years ago people were comparing him to
Micheal Vick. This was when Troy was running the with the scout teams in 2002 and the coaching staff at that time were crediting him for making our N/C team a much better team defensively. Troy is not seeing open receivers yet but given time he will correct that.

 

[Buckeyeskickbuttocks]

Well what if you could choose who to run Tosu offense?

Then I'd have another reason to take Smith, he already knows the plays.

 

[smith288]

Then I'd have another reason to take Smith, he already knows the plays.

lol

 

[JohnnyCockfight]

Terrell Owens would rather have Brett Favre run our offense.

 

[jimotis4heisman]

Uhhhh, after watching today's games, I take Troy 100-100 times. No question.

one thing to consider, one guy was going against the 111th defense in the country, the other a top 3 defense. fwiw

 

[BB73]

one thing to consider, one guy was going against the 111th defense in the country, the other a top 3 defense. fwiw

Was it Miami or Illinois that was at #3 in defense before yesterday? :tongue2:

 

[Buckeyeskickbuttocks]

Jimotis - Call me crazy, but I don't think these numbers:

Vick-69.0 pass. percent, 1534 pass yards,11-5 tdown/Int, 319 rushing yards

Smith-59.7 pass percent,1265 pass yards,10-3 tdown/Int, 378 rushing yards

Are just yesterday's stats, thus it doens't much matter about which O went against which D yesterday.

 

[Magua]

Lets keep in mind that Vtech has played NOBODY besides Miami. Their second best opponent has been Boston College.

 

[Buckeyeskickbuttocks]

Lets keep in mind that Vtech has played NOBODY besides Miami. Their second best opponent has been Boston College.

So very true.

Yep, give me Smith over Vick every day of the week, and two times on Saturday.

 

[Magua]

I watched that game with a couple guys' I work with last night, who grew up in Florida so they're BIG Hurricane fans(yuck), and they definately opened my eyes alot to whats been going on in the ACC. Did anyone else notice Vick had more turnovers than pass completions btw?

VICK FOR HEISMAN!

 

[Jeffcat]

as for the osu offense i would take smith however as a raw qb im not sure. i watched vick quite a few times this year and he definitely looks impressive on his vision and release. he also is more pocket oriented than his brother but if he needs to run he will almost always get the first down. vicks definitely the better athlete but its hard to tell how good he really is. im not ready to write him off after one bad game. smith reminds me more of a mcnabb type player with more running involved(although thats changed lately) and vick reminds me of......well vick just more pass oriented. no offense to vince young but id take troy smith over vince young any time. im still not buying the vince young can of soup.