Whitner on penalized hit: ‘I think I’m just supposed to let them catch a TD now’
Posted on September 28, 2013
Another week, another penalized hit … another incorrect call by an unofficial?
That’s Donte Whitner’s stance after the 49ers safety was flagged for an unnecessary roughness penalty for his end-zone hit on Rams wide receiver Chris Givens on Thursday night.
Givens soared high to grab a would-be 12-yard touchdown, but Whitner separated him from the ball with a jarring left-shoulder-to-the-helmet shot.
Incompletion. Penalty flag.
“I think I’m just supposed to let them catch a touchdown now,” Whitner said on SiriusXM NFL Radio on Friday (audio
here). “I think that’s what the National Football League wants, but I’m not going to give them that. I’m going to continue to play physical, continue to hit the right way, lead with my shoulder, and I’m not targeting anybody’s head.”
In Week 3, Whitner had a similar message for the NFL after he was assessed an unsportsmanlike penalty for hitting Colts running back Ahmad Bradshaw with the crown of his helmet. Replays, however, showed Whitner hit Bradshaw with his shoulder. The NFL subsequently said the hit was legal and Whitner wouldn’t be fined.
“I guess it was a big hit,” Whitner said after the loss to the Colts. “Any big hit now in the National Football League is automatically a flag.”
On Thursday, Whitner clearly delivered a shoulder to Givens’ facemask, snapping the wideout’s head back. Whitner noted the difficulty of avoiding an offensive player’s head in such a situation. Whitner raced over to hit Givens, who was in mid-air and coming down with the ball when he was belted.
“For a guy that’s going up to catch a football and coming down, it’s hard to find where to hit him,” Whitner said. “And I even backed off a little bit, turned and gave him my shoulder. So I don’t know what I was supposed to do in that situation or what they want me to do.”
Whitner plans to appeal if he’s fined for the hit. Noting his hit on Bradshaw, he’s hopeful an appeal won’t be necessary.
“They gave me a 15-yard flag and two days later they called the 49ers and said it wasn’t a flag, it was a legal play and I wouldn’t be fined,” he said. “So it looks like it could possibly be the same thing two weeks in a row.”