I'm going to reserve judgment on TP until his Sr year.
I didn't see anything in 2004 from Troy Smith that forecast he would dissect defenses with surgical precision in 2006, but somewhere midway through the 2005 season the light went on, and the tales of his taking film to Daniels and Bollman became the stuff of lore by the time his career was through.
TP has more physical ability than 90% of D1A starters. It's all in his head. He has to decide he wants to become a pocket passer and film room junkie, and when he does, if he ever does, he could be a great one. Right now, I think he thinks he knows what he's looking at when he's watching film, but he doesn't. Not yet.
One thing I saw against NMSU -- and I think it's significant even though it was NMSU -- was that he finally showed a true full-speed running gait on two of his scrambles, including a little stutter step/setting up the stiff arm on a LB, which I had never, ever seen from him before. I think he's beginning to turn the corner.
The question is whether the level of competition over these next three weeks allows us to see him blossom this year, or if we'll have to wait until next year.
I'm confident the OSU staff can get him there ... will get him there.
I didn't see anything in 2004 from Troy Smith that forecast he would dissect defenses with surgical precision in 2006, but somewhere midway through the 2005 season the light went on, and the tales of his taking film to Daniels and Bollman became the stuff of lore by the time his career was through.
TP has more physical ability than 90% of D1A starters. It's all in his head. He has to decide he wants to become a pocket passer and film room junkie, and when he does, if he ever does, he could be a great one. Right now, I think he thinks he knows what he's looking at when he's watching film, but he doesn't. Not yet.
One thing I saw against NMSU -- and I think it's significant even though it was NMSU -- was that he finally showed a true full-speed running gait on two of his scrambles, including a little stutter step/setting up the stiff arm on a LB, which I had never, ever seen from him before. I think he's beginning to turn the corner.
The question is whether the level of competition over these next three weeks allows us to see him blossom this year, or if we'll have to wait until next year.
I'm confident the OSU staff can get him there ... will get him there.
Upvote
0