Ginn & Juice
I enjoy home-made ice cream
Which do like better? Madden or NCAA Football?
Madden
Madden
-
Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
- Thread starter Ginn & Juice
- Start date
OhioState49
Hall of Fame
NCAA Football because of the classic games, mascot games, and winning an NC with OSU over and over again!
Upvote
0
barlow1802
Troy Has Legs
ncaa.. im hoping some of maddens new features will be on ncaa for 07 on ps3
Upvote
0
scarletngrey11
All right, all right, all right.
NCAA, because of the recruiting. Madden has better graphics and the hit stick is easier though...
Upvote
0
BuckeyeKid789
Guest
NCAA because college football is soooo much better than professional football.
Upvote
0
Buckeye513
Stable Genius
Creating plays, eh? There's this one where there are like 3 RBs in the background... so many options. See if you can make up something like that
Madden.
Upvote
0
jc_ultimate
Jon's Roommate
I like NCAA since I like watching it more. Madden is usually the better title as far pure gaming goes though.
Upvote
0
TheMightyQuinn
"The future is bright at Ohio State."
I love college football so much more than NFL, but Madden is the flagship for EA football, so Madden always gets the better graphics and gameplay.
Upvote
0
I love the pageantry, recruiting and NCs of NCAA. That's why I buy it every year.
However, the gameplay is years behind Madden. My buddy and I play both (and import our NCAA class and draft the kids in Madden).
The way the defense plays is mindboggling. They will regularly not tackle a guy they are running alongside. Or they will be standing and waiting for a lob pass, and then move out of the way at the last second. Don't even get me on the horrible pursuit angles.
The impact player is a fun idea, but it gets annoying that you can count on them breaking a tackle 98% of the time. Not a fan of how arcade-ish they made the game. Tapping A to break a tackle is dumb if you ask me. I think you should be able to come in with your head down and ram thru someone, but not sit there for 2 seconds tapping A, then suddenly breaking free and going for good yardage.
NCAA lets you get away with the same types of plays, and get away on athleticism. I find the defense to be much more intelligent, and therefore it requires better playcalling. The defense also adjusts better to what you are doing, especially if you are trying to overload one side of the line or leave it empty.
However, the gameplay is years behind Madden. My buddy and I play both (and import our NCAA class and draft the kids in Madden).
The way the defense plays is mindboggling. They will regularly not tackle a guy they are running alongside. Or they will be standing and waiting for a lob pass, and then move out of the way at the last second. Don't even get me on the horrible pursuit angles.
The impact player is a fun idea, but it gets annoying that you can count on them breaking a tackle 98% of the time. Not a fan of how arcade-ish they made the game. Tapping A to break a tackle is dumb if you ask me. I think you should be able to come in with your head down and ram thru someone, but not sit there for 2 seconds tapping A, then suddenly breaking free and going for good yardage.
NCAA lets you get away with the same types of plays, and get away on athleticism. I find the defense to be much more intelligent, and therefore it requires better playcalling. The defense also adjusts better to what you are doing, especially if you are trying to overload one side of the line or leave it empty.
I don't think you can use create-a-play for anythign but play now (ie not for franchise games).
Upvote
0